QuillHub
QuillHub
EN

Architecture School: Studio Culture, Critique, and Practice

25:0435 спикеров
24:58
длительность
14
главы
35
спикеры
7
Идеи
studio culturecritiquearchitecture educationpractice vs schooldesign processpedagogysustainability

Спикеры

35
Спикер A16%11 реплик
Спикер B1%1 реплика
Спикер C2%2 реплики
Спикер D7%5 реплик
Спикер E8%8 реплик
Спикер F9%10 реплик
Спикер G5%4 реплики
Спикер H1%1 реплика
Спикер I0%1 реплика
Спикер J11%4 реплики
Спикер K0%1 реплика
Спикер L2%2 реплики
Спикер M0%1 реплика
Спикер N4%1 реплика
Спикер O1%1 реплика
Спикер P0%1 реплика
Спикер Q1%1 реплика
Спикер R0%1 реплика
Спикер S2%2 реплики
Спикер T2%1 реплика
Спикер U2%1 реплика
Спикер V4%2 реплики
Спикер W6%2 реплики
Спикер X3%1 реплика
Спикер Y0%1 реплика
Спикер Z2%2 реплики
AA0%1 реплика
AB1%1 реплика
AC2%2 реплики
AD4%2 реплики
AE2%1 реплика
AF1%1 реплика
AG0%1 реплика
AH0%1 реплика
AI0%1 реплика

Основные идеи

7
  • The design studio is the core of architectural education—a social, public laboratory that shapes work and identity.
  • Critique (jury) is essential and should provoke thought rather than serve as a sales pitch or empty praise.
  • Architecture requires both creative (artistic) and pragmatic (technical, economic) modes of thinking simultaneously.
  • Schools should be experimental laboratories but must also better prepare students for real-world constraints and collaboration.
  • The existing pedagogical focus on producing 'star architects' is flawed; education should support diverse, socially useful practices.

Важные моменты

7
  • Studio culture described as a 'second home' and a persistent, collaborative environment where ideas are exchanged at random hours.
  • A good critique inspires thought and debate; mere praise is not useful.
  • The 'design high'—students staying up thinking about projects—illustrates the intense personal investment in design.
  • Tension between idealized academic freedom and the need to introduce real-world constraints into education.
  • Criticism of the 'star architect' pedagogical model and endorsement of broader, socially oriented practices.

Термины

7
design studio — a shared educational workspace where architecture students develop projects, receive critique, and collaborate socially and intellectually.
critique/jury — a public evaluative session where student work is presented and reviewed by peers and faculty; intended to provoke critical thinking.
structural system — the arrangement of load-bearing elements (beams, walls, spans) that support a building; used here in critique to question feasibility.
retaining wall — a wall built to hold back soil or earth; mentioned both literally and metaphorically ('retaining memories').
iterative process — repeated cycles of making, testing, evaluating, and revising design work.

Основное содержание

14 глав · 24:58
0:03

1. What is Architecture? The Architect's Role

Спикер A0:03

It captures people's imagination, I think, first and foremost. Architecture does affect people in ways that maybe architects understand only after a building's built.

Спикер B0:18

People perceive architecture as simply being an object or a vessel within which people are housed, and that's clearly not what our sense of architecture is.

Спикер C0:33

What the hell is an architect? What does an architect do? You know, what is the difference between an architect and a builder?

Спикер D0:44

We concretize the world. We take human activities, and we make manifest the physical structures that accommodate all manner of human activity.

Спикер A1:01

A design studio is a place where individual action and individual creativity are measured very directly by the people around them.

Спикер D1:13

When students are doing their job, they're shifting the focus of how we're talking and thinking about architecture.

Спикер E1:50

Before you kind of come to architecture school, you sort of have this idea about objects and things like that. And then, once you get here, it becomes all about space and, you know, all about occupation.

People sort of see a lot, you know, architecture sort of sculpturally, and there's a point at which you stop dealing with objects, you know, sort of things to stare at, and you start dealing with occupation.

Спикер F2:11

I have a lot of friends who find it really hard to understand, like, my schedule here and how we function here, and being here at strange hours of the day, and the working environment, and what studio space is like.

Спикер E2:22

And the way of working, too, you know, that's really important.

2:26

2. Studio Culture and Architectural Education

Спикер F2:26

And also the idea of being critiqued.

Спикер E2:27

Like, being critiqued is, it's a foreign concept to a business student.

Спикер A2:34

Yeah. The design studio is a place where students have to perform on their own. They have to create something from their own imagination. They have to create something in response to a set of problems that are either given to them or they have to even invent the problem.

Спикер F3:19

There's no other place that you can get this kind of culture, and we've been together for 5 years, like the whole group, right?

So we know everybody. Everybody knows everything. It's like a second home. It's like a second community of people who are all struggling with the same questions.

Спикер G3:39

Now, when I worked, yeah, when I worked at home, there was so much lacking in the projects. There's nobody to bounce things off of. The inspiration is at a minimum when you're on your own.

Спикер H3:49

Architecture education in the U.S. is one of the best because of the students. They always hang around their own studio, talking and learning from others. That is the most important space for the education of architecture.

Спикер I4:05

It's like him—

Спикер J4:05

They were hating on Robert Moses because he's so insensitive, and he tore down neighborhoods and this, that, and the other. It's like, you know what, get in a car, drive, drive on the West Side Highway, take the Triborough Bridge into Manhattan, and then you will, you will understand what he was trying to do.

That visual procession in the automobile, spectacular. No, no. It is spectacular. You're thinking about it now because the automobile, oh yeah, of course. Now we sit in traffic and we look at it.

4:31

3. Studio Dynamics: Public Critique and Community Life

Спикер D4:31

But back then, like, the city had to make that transformation.

Спикер A4:35

The great thing about architecture schools is it still takes place in a kind of space where people discuss the work together, in a kind of both a personal way, a one-on-one way, and in a very public way.

Ultimately, there's a kind of arena; there's a public arena where the work is discussed, where students can present themselves personally to other people and show that they have a stake in the work and what they really think about the work.

And that's extremely important, I think, to the development of an architectural project because that's ultimately how architecture, at certain points, has really developed in the real world. It's both an important lesson, but it's also a way in which, you know, through that kind of intensely personal and human contact, that the work gets better.

Спикер F5:43

I think a lot of the culture of studio happens at the most random times, like the most random hours.

Спикер G5:53

I hope that—yes. I think the humor adds another level of energy, you know, that you can bring.

So you've got moments where, you know, we're all like joking around, and yeah, we're doing the work, and we're joking, and we're vibing, and whatever. Some guy will come in here like, "Well, you know, that's why you guys don't get any work done, because you're always doing this shit."

Fuck you. Go and do your project then and, like, you know, live in your little world by yourself, 'cause the humor brings the interaction, and the interaction brings the energy, and the energy, you know, creates an output between everybody, you know, that we can all feed off of.

Спикер K6:31

Don't forget, D.

Спикер F6:32

The Buddha belly. The bounce.

6:36

4. Intensity of Studio Work: Late Nights and Design Obsession

Спикер L6:36

Everyone stays late. Everyone's hanging out and smoking cigarettes and drinking a lot of coffee and not really necessarily at your desk drawing or whatever.

Architecture school is a really strange, specific environment. You can't possibly put that much work into something, like hours and hours on, you know, one drawing or whatever, and make it be productive. You know, you could tell an architect that it's due tomorrow, and they'll put in the 12 hours, and it might actually look the same as if they spent a whole week on it, you know?

Спикер E7:02

I should have gone home earlier than I did because I just, like, every 5 minutes, I would take a little bit of glue and put it somewhere, and then stop. And figure out what the hell it is that I just did, and then start over again.

Спикер F7:16

I have this terrible thing that happens to me that I call the design high, where I can't fall asleep because I can't stop thinking about my project.

And it's like I get home, and the whole walk home I'm exhausted, and as soon as I brush my teeth and wash my face and get into bed, I need to go back to work.

Спикер M7:37

Your health is kind of put on hold to make room for your ideas.

Спикер N7:44

Architects are masochists in some ways. You're in there, you're in there to all hours of the night. You're cutting yourself at 3 o'clock in the morning. You're rushing to the hospital to get stitched. I mean, you're putting these models together that you're tearing apart and then putting them together again, and then you're going through this iterative process of evaluation that is incredibly personal.

But yet also very public, and you're constantly putting yourself on display, opening yourself up to attack and criticism. I mean, it's intense. Why would you subject yourself to that and put yourself through that if you didn't love it?

Oh, fuck! Ah! God, fuck!

Спикер O8:38

That's a conceptual mistake. A structural system does not separate between each unit. Usually, the span of structure encompasses 3 or 4 units, or maybe more.

8:51

5. Critique and the Jury Process

Спикер A8:51

Well, I understand, but I don't see why that has to necessarily be the case, especially—

Спикер P8:54

It would necessarily be the case.

Спикер A8:57

I understand that I don't have to, but I think it's important for the, you know, resolution.

Спикер Q9:02

It's fine. It's wrong. Why is it wrong? Tell us why it's wrong. Economically. It's not wrong. Systems. We could critique his whole project in terms of the economy of it. No, but you don't— Basically, they're these walls, Dan.

Спикер R9:17

In terms of his diagram, it's how the economy is structured. Yeah, those have to be every other third wall in structure.

Спикер E9:22

I mean, then that completely ruins the areas of critique. It does not ruin anything. It wasn't necessary to have that conversation. The point was made, and then that's it. I understood the point; they understood my—or I thought he understood my point. I thought that should be the end of it, and then there were more important things to talk about and other people that had to talk to them, you know? And still talking about it for 20 minutes.

Спикер J9:42

One thing that I always have an issue with is, like, students get so frustrated if they don't have a good critique. I think they misinterpret what a good critique is. I mean, by definition, it's a critique. It's a criticism.

So if somebody goes— if you go into a critique and all the critics, all they can do is blow hot air up your ass and tell you how great the project looks, well, that's still not— to me, that's not a good critique. They didn't criticize anything.

To me, a good criticism is if you can inspire enough thought based on what they see and what they hear. If it inspires enough thought, then they will criticize. Not criticize in the sense of attacking. They're going to criticize because whatever you showed them inspired enough thought that they have their own opinion about the thing now. That's a criticism.

Спикер D10:28

I'm not going to argue with you because I have a feeling it wouldn't be productive. We could go on all night. We could. I know that's not the point. If you would stop and listen occasionally, we'd be able to find, you know, some resting spot here where we're kind of talking about the same thing if you allow us to help you.

Спикер C10:49

The other thing I think that is sometimes very negative is the idea that the student should be trained to do a sales pitch in this jury process. I mean, I think that really probably the student should at first be silent, you know, and the jurors should really start to ask questions about the drawings and try to understand the projects in a more Socratic way, you know, rather than this sales pitch followed by criticism.

11:15

6. Clarity of Thought and Architectural Thinking

Спикер A11:15

If you're a smart architecture student, you're listening very closely because you're not only interested in how that work is coming out of you, but also how other people are seeing it.

Спикер S11:51

The best architects, in my view, are the ones who bring a coherent view of the world to design. Those are the folks that become the best architects, in the sense that they're the ones that progress the profession, innovate, and create new ideas. The most important thing about being an architect is learning how to think clearly.

Спикер A12:12

You have to be able to think clearly to practice architecture.

Спикер D12:20

There's a tendency to see people as singular. If you're artistic, you're not practical. If you're practical, you're not artistic. That's totally preposterous. I mean, architecture is embedded in both worlds. And if anything, architecture is the connective tissue between these two kinds of spheres.

And it'd be impossible to live in one or the other. One, you'd be practical and never produce a piece of work of any interest. The other, you'd be producing work that has no meaning or no connectivity.

Спикер T12:50

I think design requires a certain kind of smartness that holds those schizophrenic views simultaneously in one's thinking. Even as a young person, you know whether you can do that, and as you mature, it's quite rewarding to have those opposing views in your mind at all times.

13:15

7. Roles of the Architect and Imagination

Спикер U13:15

There's not just one role for an architect. There are all different kinds of contributions an architect can make in the culture.

The question of what's a good architect? I think that there are many different perspectives that come at a project as it's developing. What's important for the architect is to be able to listen to people outside of themselves and take that, and then give something of themselves to a project and make something incredibly unique and wonderful.

Спикер A13:44

It has to be a person who's really willing to learn. In a way, I think there's something that architects need to learn, which is they need to learn something every day for the rest of their lives. You've got to be, in a sense, kind of driven by that, in a sense, kind of inner force.

But I think you always— you also have to have the ability to kind of work through something and to be able to look at particular problems, and be able to kind of listen and learn and examine with great patience some of those questions.

So again, it's a kind of left brain, right brain kind of dichotomy that is, you know, constantly— those demands are constantly placed on you as an architect.

Спикер V14:27

There are other disciplines that bring other things to the table, but I think our ability to envision or imagine something that is not there, it's almost spooky to people. This notion that you can look at a site or look at a parking lot and see a building there, I think it's extraordinary.

It's an extraordinary skill, and we are one of the few disciplines that can do that. I would not trade for anything the skill set that I learned in school because it's very, very, very unique to our discipline, and that's what we bring to the table.

15:11

8. Architecture Education vs Professional Practice

Спикер W15:11

I don't believe schools of architecture, either historically or today, have particularly prepared young architects for the realities of architectural practice.

Again, referring to this notion of a safe space where one can fail, where one can push the envelope in a sense, I think the academy always needs to be that. In a certain sense, you're a bit freer of the constraints of the real world.

We need to understand that those constraints also have to be brought into the academy so students can begin dealing with them and dealing with them in an inventive and creative way. I think the academy should be a kind of idealized space, but it also has to be a kind of laboratory, a testing ground for the real world.

And I don't think we're so good with the latter. I mean, we are still that ivory tower.

Спикер F16:00

Sometimes I think we lose a little bit of the reality of what our job is and what our profession is really about. I think people really forget the reality of what it's gonna be like to be working as professionals.

Спикер L16:14

Architecture school is really unique because it's probably the only time that many architecture students get to work on their own projects. Because after that, it's, you know, architecture is basically a service industry.

Спикер E16:25

I think that the profession is a lot different from the education in that you never work alone. It's hard to design an entire building by yourself. There's always other people that you have to network with, or design with, or consult. That collaboration is not usually present in school, which is a good thing and a bad thing, because during school you're trying to develop your own sort of way of working.

Спикер X16:47

You're very fast, and you're only predicting what I'm going to say. Preparing them to become kind of architects in the full sense of the word architect, being both poets and practitioners. They are wonderful, they're talented, they're smart.

17:07

9. Integrating Poetic and Pragmatic Design

Спикер X17:07

The tragedy is that the students are not sufficiently prepared to be independent thinkers. They either function at a poetic level, or they function at a pragmatic level. The two shall never meet. So we have to kind of help them put those two together.

Спикер Y17:26

Do like a series of overlays where you'd start to see, like, if there's different spaces like this, how they would interact.

Спикер Z17:31

So, the walls are retaining walls. They're retaining earth.

AA17:35

They're retaining memories. It's like an earthwork, yeah.

Спикер Z17:38

But, like, if you give me a word like that, we can all respond to it, right?

17:42

10. Career Paths and Student Aspirations

Спикер Z17:42

Let me ask you this. Why are they working just to put these things? They're making things, right? And they're making things because they want to create something of value, right? Why do they just want to put it in storage?

Спикер F17:58

Do I think I might not be an architect? Sure. The likelihood that I work in an office after I graduate is pretty high, though. I don't think that people have to be stuck there for like three years and then get their license, and then they do their own stuff. I want to start doing my own stuff and work in an office.

Спикер G18:14

I look forward to—I look forward to seeing what's going to happen. I'm excited to see what my signature ends up being.

AB18:24

I want to teach, and I want to write, and I want to work for a firm that will let me do all of these things.

Спикер E18:32

I want to get some experience in a larger firm to see how they work and see how they operate. Do that, and then hopefully the long-term goal is to, you know, start my own practice.

18:44

11. Optimism in Architecture and the Myth of the Star Architect

Спикер W18:44

The remarkable thing to me is how optimistic students of architecture are, how they sustain that optimism.

And again, it's almost a bit like an actor or actress, that they still cherish that belief that they're gonna break out of the chorus line in some way, even though the reality, as it is on Broadway, is very, very different.

In part, it could be how they very quickly imbibed this notion of the star architect and this belief that, against all odds, they might be able to make it.

AC19:22

Well, today I think a lot of people, when they think of architecture, they think of what? Star architects. They think of, well, the handful of brand-name architects that they might have heard of, which to me is rather limiting.

Спикер F19:33

People only know Frank Gehry, you know. I mean, there's other architects out there that are doing better work, greater work, more important work than Gehry.

Спикер S19:42

The problem is that the way we teach architecture right now is we teach—we sort of train everybody to do that exact same thing. The whole sort of pedagogical model right now is around creating the next generation of star architects.

Спикер A19:54

That's actually a flawed model.

AD19:57

For many years, everyone wanted to be like Frank Gehry. They wanted to create great sculptures in the landscape. Whether those sculptures worked or not was largely irrelevant. The ability to use aerospace engineering to come up with forms that hadn't been built before was considered to be a primary task of someone coming out of school.

That's over. That's over.

20:32

12. Students' Role: Technology, Shelter, and Social Responsibility

AE20:32

I would argue that this current generation of beginning students of architecture have the capacity to reshape a world like we've never seen before, and it—and they need to have access to as much technology and as much meaningful discourse surrounding these techniques and these tools, so that they're fully prepared to go out into the world in the future to do something positive and productive.

AD21:02

Students are coming out. They're working with individuals around the world who need shelter and who need ways of living that are affordable, supportable, and sustainable. The students themselves have been pushing to force faculty to think differently about the way faculty see the environment, use the environment, and create objects that serve not just the aesthetic interests of the architect.

Спикер V21:31

It's fundamentally an optimistic profession. You don't go into architecture if you're a pessimist, if you don't actually believe that the world can get better.

Спикер A21:42

So, I think you've got a bunch of optimists that go into this design profession who actually believe that their buildings are going to make the difference in somebody's life.

Спикер F21:50

I think that the built environment is something that people have such an underappreciation for. If you don't care about this, then, like, what do you care about? It's about understanding human behavior, human desire, human want.

Architecture is what you experience in your daily life. On the street, the space of the street, how you navigate the street, how you relate to the buildings around you.

22:17

13. Everyday Architecture and the School's Creative Ethos

AC22:17

People tend to think architecture is done for and by other people. It's, you know, it's also done by you if you decide to maybe put a new window in your house or change the traffic flow in your house or your office.

Спикер J22:35

In architecture school, you got the freedom to—

AF22:38

You don't like something? Do something about it. That's what they told you for five years. Do something about it. Doesn't matter what, just do something about it.

Спикер E22:46

The school is kind of about a way of thinking, and what you're going to do in architecture school is not what you think it's going to be, you know? That you're not going to go in there and, you know, be designing colonial homes and things like that.

Спикер G23:00

We need shelter, we need atmosphere, and we need to be inspired. I think one of the most important things you can take from this school is not to lose your ambition. It's not just, you know, four walls and a roof. There's more to it. There's like a life to it that I think we get here, and we should really take with us everywhere we go.

23:24

14. The Creative Process and Informal Conclusion

Спикер J23:24

If you're gonna come to architecture school, I hope, I hope you understand the creative process. I hope you understand the transformation that your body—mind and body and psyche—is gonna go through. Because there is nothing absolute about this.

AG24:48

What? Huh? You bounce? I will once in a while.

AH24:52

What do you think about that, Mr. Doc Boy? Yeah, making a movie, huh?

AI24:58

Yeah, sure you are. Yo, where did you go?