Career and Persistence in Pluto Exploration

13:202 speakers
12:57
duration
8
chapters
2
speakers
7
Ideas
Pluto explorationplanetary sciencecareer motivationpersistence

Speakers

2
Speaker A32%11 turns
Speaker B68%11 turns

Key ideas

7
  • Early fascination with space and astronomy guided the speaker's career choice.
  • Interest in planetary science grew because planets could be visited by spacecraft.
  • Pluto was attractive as a research focus because it was poorly known.
  • A group of like-minded scientists worked together to persuade NASA to explore Pluto.
  • The campaign to get a Pluto mission took many years and faced repeated cancellations.

Key highlights

6
  • Speaker's childhood: voracious reading, model building, and contacting NASA.
  • Pluto seen as a near-unknown compared with Mars or Venus, offering broad discovery potential.
  • It took 14 years to get NASA interested and 26 years in total to achieve the mission goal.
  • Multiple multi-year mission proposals were canceled over roughly a 12-year span.
  • Senior advisors warned the speaker that persistence on Pluto might harm their career.

Decisions

3
  • A group of young scientists decided to unite and campaign to convince NASA to mount a mission to Pluto.
  • NASA repeatedly decided to cancel multiple proposed approaches to a Pluto mission during the campaign.
  • Ultimately a decision was reached (by NASA and the project leaders) to proceed with a mission to Pluto, achieved after prolonged effort.

Terms

4
planetary science — The scientific study of planets, moons, and related bodies in the solar system.
spacecraft — A vehicle or device designed for travel or operation in outer space.
NASA — The U.S. National Aeronautics and Space Administration, responsible for civilian space programs and aerospace research.
Pluto mission — A space exploration mission specifically designed to study the dwarf planet Pluto (context: long-term campaign described).

Main content

8 chapters · 12:57
0:02

1. Choosing a Career in Space

Speaker A0:02

As a start, I guess I would really love if you, you know, if you give me an idea, and you can walk me through the process of you being interested in this field and you deciding that you want to do this for a living, essentially.

Speaker B0:23

Yeah, well, in my case, I was just fascinated by early space exploration when I was a.

Speaker A0:33

Child.

Speaker B0:33

Yeah. And captivated by the television coverage of it. I can remember as a boy reading voraciously about it, checking out every book in the library, subscribing to magazines, building models, writing to NASA, and all that. I just never found anything else I wanted to do more. So, I studied the appropriate subjects in university, and I was fortunate to be able to have a career in this.

1:15

2. Early Influences and Lasting Fascination

Speaker A1:15

And you sort of, you know, mentioned that. What was the, you know, first thing that kind of captivated your attention? Um, but do you have like a clear memory or moment where you seen something and you, you know, you got your mind absolutely blown?

Speaker B1:36

Um, not a specific moment as if there was one. It was really an accumulation for me of many things that I saw and read about. You know, when I was a boy, the exploration of space and particularly astronomy and what became called planetary science seemed like something so much larger than life and a part of, you know, the sweep of human history.

Yeah, it was amazing to me that there were careers that people could participate in if they were good at what they did. I always aspired to it. But it really wasn't one moment so much as it was the constant media attention around science and technology and particularly space exploration.

2:42

3. Family Opposition and Early Doubts

Speaker A2:42

Yeah, I see. Was it a moment where it was difficult for you to, um, you know, to pursue this road? Um, or was it, um, you know, or was it difficult for you to maintain that initial passion and fascination that you had throughout the journey? Or was it always— or you're the type of person who is very strict on the motivations and the incentive that you have to follow that?

Speaker B3:19

Well, there were certainly times in my career when I questioned if this was the right path. And when I was finishing high school and in university, my parents really did not want me to do this. Oh, and that's a strong influence. They thought that it was a bad choice. Yeah.

And in, you know, in looking back on it, I think if I'd been less committed, they might have steered me to something else. But I really felt strongly committed, and so I never made a change.

4:14

4. From Astronomy to Planetary Science

Speaker A4:14

Yeah, and throughout, you know, throughout your journey in establishing your career path, how did your interests and topics of interest change? How did, I guess, your taste or fascination develop through your further learning about this field?

Speaker B4:41

Well, I was always very interested in astronomy, and as I got into university, I realized that my interest in space exploration and my interest in astronomy dovetailed. They came together with the study of the planets because, unlike faraway astronomy—studying stars and galaxies and the origin of the universe—the planets were places we could actually hope to visit with our spacecraft.

Speaker A5:18

Yeah.

Speaker B5:18

And because I have a very strong interest in exploration, in addition to science, that was a very good combination for me.

5:34

5. Becoming Involved with Pluto Exploration

Speaker A5:34

Interesting. And obviously, you know, you've been so heavily involved with the exploration of Pluto and the exploration of, you know, the places in space that are so far beyond most people's imagination.

How this particular topic came to you, and how— can you just talk to me a bit more about the whole involvement, from your side, towards this specific field?

Speaker B6:08

Well, in the beginning of my interest in planetary science, I was hired by a research professor who was doing research on many subjects in planetary science, one of which was Pluto. He offered me a project. At that time, we knew very little—very, very little—about Pluto, but I was fascinated by it because so little was known. I thought, whereas we knew—or at that time we knew—a lot about Mars and Venus, for example, Pluto was essentially a complete unknown. We only knew a few things about it. The number of things we knew about Pluto you could probably write on a single card, you know, a small piece of paper.

So that was attractive to me because it seemed that any progress was important progress, as opposed to focusing on some narrow issue in, for example, the study of Mars. And then, as I began doing the work that I was doing, I saw that spacecraft had been to all the planets or were on their way to every planet except Pluto. It seemed to me a challenge that Pluto should be explored.

What I found was that there were a number of other then young scientists and technologists who were of a similar mind. We bound together as a group to try to convince NASA to mount a mission to Pluto. It turned out that that was a very difficult challenge. It took 14 years to achieve our goal, and that is just to get NASA to be interested and to plan to do a mission to Pluto. It took 26 years.

8:40

6. Developing the Pluto Mission: Challenges and Persistence

Speaker A8:40

That's actually, you know, leads to another of my questions because I read a lot about the whole process and how long it took, and so on and so forth.

And obviously, this, as you mentioned, involves a great collective of people. How difficult was it for you, as you know, a leading name in this whole process, to maintain motivation and the vision of everyone involved in order to make this project happen? Because I can only imagine how, you know, how devastating this long waiting and going through the different processes can affect your motivation to do something like that?

Speaker B9:33

Well, at first, our work was very well received, and it seemed almost too easy that we were making progress quickly.

But then we found that that was kind of a false dawn, if you will. What we thought was becoming a start on a mission to Pluto was not, and that NASA wanted to make a change and cancel everything we'd done and try something else.

But I was very enthusiastic, so I was happy to work on a different way. As it turned out, NASA repeatedly canceled each and every approach to obtaining a mission to Pluto. This involved five separate multi-year efforts, all of which were canceled over a period of about 12 years.

Speaker A10:43

Okay.

Speaker B10:43

And I was advised, you know, I was very early in my career. I was advised by much more senior people that I should just forget about this and that it wasn't good for my career because I was too persistent.

But I continued to persist, and so did others. I did not do this alone. And ultimately, we triumphed.

11:20

7. Admiration for Long-term Vision and Persistence

Speaker A11:20

It's, you know, it's interesting that you've mentioned that because it—what really drew my interest to, you know, to your case and specifically talking to you was exactly this level of, you know, being a visionary and maintaining your passion towards such an idea for such a prolonged amount of time.

Which ultimately leads to such a big progress towards the, you know, the human science, and it's just very, you know, I'm just very impressed by that. I think what you've done in having this mission and just not, you know, letting it go—it's such a.

I can only imagine what has been through to you personally to go through this whole process.

12:15

8. Team Effort, Leadership, and Humility in Spaceflight

Speaker B12:15

Well, thank you. And I just remind you that spaceflight is always a team effort, that I am probably the best-known person associated with the exploration of Pluto because I led the project and still lead it. But no spaceflight's ever been done by one person. Thousands of men and women were involved who worked enormous amounts over years, thousands of people. So I don't want to get all the credit. I just happen to be a little hardheaded and set on a goal.

Speaker A12:56

Yeah.

Speaker B12:57

And ultimately, I was very lucky that many things turned out right, and we got to do it. It turned out well in many respects. Yeah.